I just got done watching Rajkumar Hirani and Aamir Khan’s
PK. This blog is not particularly ‘inspired’ by it, but yes, the film
definitely instigated me into writing this blog today. Let me also make one
thing very clear, I didn’t quite like the movie. In fact, other than bits of the
end, it was quite a pain to sit through the whole film especially the scenes
with Donald Duck in it. The movie in itself was quite ridiculous (like most other
Raju Hirani films) but I’m glad it did some good towards the end.
Also, just for clarity, I know Hirani has made just about 4
films but I say ‘most’ when I talk about his films that I didn’t like because
other than Lage Raho Munnabhai I haven’t quite liked any of his other movies.
Munnabhai MBBS was a little lame to be honest, I saw 3 Idiots twice just to see
what the fuss was about but I could never figure, and now PK has yet again been
quite a disappointment. Despite this, I quite respect the man for a fact that
his films try and show some good. It’s like there is a message in all his films
which people could really learn from. This is especially true of Lage Raho, 3
Idiots, and even PK.
There are some more facts that I’d like to clear before I
proceed. I don’t believe in any God or religion per se. I was born into a Hindu
family and I still live with them and I live in a community where we celebrate
all festivals irrespective of what religion they are from. I don’t pray to any
one God or through any religious practice and I don’t go to any religious
establishment for any religious reasons. I may visit a church for its mystique,
a temple for its architecture, a mosque for my curiosity, or a Gurudwara for
its halwa.
What PK has tried to show in the film is probably through
good intentions but it failed at so many levels. Firstly, the movie is so fake
that nothing in the film is believable. None of the characters make sense and
the whole film feels like an intellectual Rohit Shetty flick. The humour was
not the kind I like, which was the case for both 3 Idiots and Munnabhai MBBS as
well. The Hindu bashing was quite senseless at times and apart from the good
intentions of the film, everything else failed. In fact, one of the songs just took
me back to the ‘Janae Nahi… Denge Tujhe…’
song from 3 Idiots and I was half expecting Rancho or a Chatur to come on
screen and fart.
In spite of everything failing, I must give Mr. Hirani a
standing ovation for at least trying to bridge some gap between Hindus and
Muslims, that too from India and Pakistan respectively, towards the end.
Towards the end we also see how the film is not about any one religion in
particular, as some Hindus are saying it is anti-Hindu, but it is against the
concept of this ‘God’ that we ourselves have created. This alien was not
against the concept of ‘God’ that created us but rather the whore that we’ve
created out of it during our evolution. But all Hindus across the world taking
it so personally and asking for a ban on the film brings me to the real topic here
that I wish to talk about, which is the title of the blog as well.
Today, I have to admit, in whatever capacity that I am a
Hindu, I am ashamed to be one. I know I’m not a practicing Hindu, I know I don’t
believe in God, I know I don’t go to temples, I know don’t pray to the Gods, so
whatever little connection I have with Hinduism, it makes me feel stupid to be
a part of it. After a point in life, after a certain age, I never needed
religion to tell me that I needed to do good or be good. I know what’s right or
wrong without fearing the consequences of what a God might do to me. I’m well
aware that all my actions will have consequences and I take decisions based on
reason. I don’t blame God when something goes wrong neither do I credit God for
the good that happens. Majority of what happens in my life is because of what I
do along with the support of my friends and family, blessings of my loved ones,
some amount of luck, and lots and lots of hard work or the lack of it.
So when I see so many Hindus today becoming extremists in
some way or the other, it just saddens me to the core. This was never the case
till a few years back. At least not in the strata of society where I belong.
Not with the circle of people that I used to hang out with. But it seems like
the same people have been brainwashed somehow by a greater power and now all
they do is try to defend their religion from an enemy that does not even exist.
By constantly defending it against an invisible enemy, they’ve managed to
create a real one out of it.
Once upon a time I used to go to temples, I used to pray
every night, I used to fear God and not do bad. It was because back then I was
a kid, I did not have the brain to make sense of a lot of practical things. I’m
glad I had this upbringing where I learned about the religion and the culture,
etc. I’m gladder that my parents gave me the option to chart my own course when
I did grow up and started to have my own thoughts as an individual which define
me today. It is out of that respect that I don’t mind sitting with my parents
during any Puja at home or going to the temple with them. It is not forced upon
me out of fear of a God. We all have our individual beliefs and we must learn
to respect each other for that.
If I can respect that you need to go to your temple or
mosque or church or Gurudwara, you must respect that I don’t need to go to any.
Chuck that, this is much bigger than what I want or don’t want. Why is it that
all of a sudden all Hindus in our country are uniting against a so called
invasion by the Muslims? Why is it that Hindus today need to get defensive
about each and every little non-Hindu thing that happens in our country? Why
are Hindus today so blind to see that PK is merely a crappy film which simply
utilises the most popular religion in our country and has not got a personal vendetta
against Hinduism?
By this logic, Americans should sue all the disaster
Hollywood films which showcase destruction of American cities because that’s
all they do apparently in each of their films. Right? But that is only because
it is an American film and they are shooting in America so it is easier to
destroy that rather than coming to India and shooting here to destroy Delhi or
recreating a Delhi in the US. Similarly, if an alien gets dropped off in India,
it is but natural that if he starts noticing religion, what he is going to encounter
most is Hinduism!
I know we were never a tolerant bunch and the Hindu-Muslim
war will continue till eternity, but it seems to be getting worse by the day.
Especially lately because of reasons that I’m sure everyone is aware of. I don’t
want to be a part of a community that practices hate outside of their temples
or mosques. I don’t want to be a part of a community which prays for peace yet
wishes ill for people of other religion. I don’t wish to be a part of a
community that is fake and gets defensive on the stupidest of topics.
Always remember, this country does not belong to Hindus or
Muslims or whoever else. It belongs to each one of its citizens irrespective of
their religion. The Hindu in Hindustan has nothing to do with Hinduism (at
least I’d like to believe so) and the current sentiment is extremely negative
even for a person like me who, maybe, at least technically, is a Hindu. There
is much more to do in the world and to worry about in the world than bloody
defend our religions against invisible enemies. Let’s fix ourselves first and
then worry about fixing others.
I’m not trying to bash Hinduism here but rather the people
who’re trying to widen the gap between Hindus and Muslims or any other religion
for that matter. I don’t discriminate between religions, rather I hate and
respect them all equally. I also recently realised that ‘deleting’ all religion
from this planet will not help us in any way possible. We are humans and we are
capable of finding excuses to kill each other any which way. So all you atheists
out there who are spending their lives’ worth in trying to destroy religion
from this planet, please give up, it is a worthless exercise. If you think it’s
religion today that’s killing us all, tomorrow it may be something else. The
problem is with us and nothing else.
The sooner we realise, the better.
